Study: Sugar — Independent of Obesity — Causes Diabetes

SugarBowl_Judy_FlickrFor years, doctors have debated sugar’s role in causing diabetes. The prevailing medical opinion has been that eating more sugar means eating more calories, and it’s the resulting weight gain that leads to diabetes. But a major new study shows a direct link between sugar and diabetes — a link that’s independent of a person’s weight.

KQED’s Stephanie Martin interviewed one of the study’s authors, Dr. Robert Lustig from UCSF. Lustig is an expert on childhood obesity and has been vocal about the health hazards of sugar for years. His video “Sugar: The Bitter Truth” has more than three million views on YouTube.

“This is the same level of proof that was available to us when we implicated cigarettes as the cause of lung cancer back in the 1960′s.”

Lustig told Martin that the study was very carefully done — researchers looked at sugar consumption in 175 countries over a decade and controlled for just about everything including obesity, poverty, and physical activity. They found that the more sugar in the food supply, the higher the rates of diabetes in that country, no matter what the obesity rates were.

In the study, sugar was 11 times stronger than total calories in explaining diabetes rates around the world. “Those countries where sugar went up showed increases in [diabetes] rates. Those countries where sugar availability went down, showed decreases in rate.”

Lustig said their findings point to proof of causation that should be accepted by doctors. “This is the same level of proof that was available to us when we implicated cigarettes as the cause of lung cancer back in the 1960′s,” he told Martin. He believes the findings are sufficiently strong to lead to policy interventions around sugar.

Lustig has long suspected sugar as a major driver of diabetes. He pointed out that diabetes afflicts people across the weight spectrum.

“Twenty percent of obese people have completely normal metabolic signatures,” Lustig told Martin. “Conversely, up to 40 percent of normal weight people have the exact same metabolic problems that the obese do; they are just not obese. The obesity is a marker for the metabolic problems which we call metabolic syndrome, rather than  a cause.” He cautioned that people who are normal weight, but eat a lot of sugar, could be sick and not know it.

The study was not designed to address whether the type of sugar mattered — for example, table sugar versus high fructose corn syrup. Lustig said that in the study researchers looked at all sugars collectively, not individually.

At present, sugar is classified by the Food and Drug Administration as “Generally Regarded As Safe.” Lustig believes the FDA should re-evaluate whether sugar should stay on that list. He has previously called for sugar to be regulated in the same way alcohol is.

Marion Nestle, professor of nutrition, food studies and public health at New York University was not affiliated with the study, but in a release she praised the research saying it was the first paper she knew of to link sugar consumption to diabetes. She said the study adds to a body of research that is sufficient to “advise people to keep their sugar a lot lower than it normally is.”

In his medical practice, Lustig says he sees adolescents with Type 2 diabetes. He asserts that one-fourth of U.S. adolescents consume at least 840 calories a day in sugar, more than 40 percent of a daily diet of 2,000 calories. “The question is,” he asked rhetorically, “what does that do to you? What does that do to your liver? What does that do to your pancreas?”

Learn More:

Sugar’s Role in Rise of Diabetes Gets Clearer (NPR)

Related
  • http://twitter.com/diabetesnews1 diabetes news

    The increase in diabetes is from artificial foods such as
    Aspartame, Sucraclose, please understand that high fructose corn
    syrup is not the same as table sugar, it is not natural

    Fake
    sugars cause insulin resistance and obesity, they are directly
    related to people not losing weight and becoming diabetic. This study
    says “Sugar in excess” is bad, well so is Milk,Eggs,cheese,
    broccoli or any other food. Artificial sweeteners make billions are
    supported by the FDA and they are the true cause of weight gain See
    here
    http://type2diabetesdietplan.blogspot.com/2013/02/can-diabetic-eat-sugar-why-it-is-only.html

    • http://twitter.com/Tebob2 Bob Johnson

      Sure, sugar is good for you, right……. munch on…… bet your BMI is up there for sure…

  • Pingback: Study: Sugar — Not Obesity — Causes Diabetes – KQED (blog) | Weight Loss Diet Plan

  • Pingback: Study: Sugar can influence diabetes – WXXA | Weight Loss Diet Plan

  • http://www.ElderRage.com/ Jacqueline Marcell

    Excellent information. Also, Alzheimer’s is now termed ‘Type 3 Diabetes’, so it is even more important to eliminate sugar, processed and high-glycemic carbs to reduce insulin spikes, which reduces hunger so we can get to a healthy weight. That is challenging for everyone to do until we understand the science of how these foods have hijacked our brains and addicted us with surges of pleasurable dopamine. But once we embrace the science, it is easier to go through the withdrawal and get to the other side of it. After caring for two parents with Alzheimer’s, writing a book about it, and then going through
    invasive breast cancer, I was finally able to eliminate addicting foods and it was
    a shock that all cravings magically disappeared.

    -Jacqueline Marcell, Author, ‘Elder Rage’, International Speaker on Alzheimer’s

  • Matthew

    So, we’re saying that our research abilities today are no better than four decades ago? Seriously, I have no doubt that certain kinds of sugar are linked to diabetes, and likely even an excess use of sugar in general. But, it is just absurd to claim that all sugars should be government regulated based on a statistical study that doesn’t have any medical evidence to back it up. We might have first realized that cigarettes were a health risk based on statistics, but we now have very conclusive medical research and many samples of black lungs from deceased cigarette smokers to back that up. I applaud Dr. Robert Lustig for helping to steer us in the right direction as it is definitely worthwhile for individuals to consider limiting sugar intake based on this information. However, it is absolutely foolish to believe this information is enough to warrant government regulation.

    • http://twitter.com/Tebob2 Bob Johnson

      Sorry about your obvious love for, and addiction to, sugar there…..