Donate

Judge Denies Mirkarimi Motion to Overturn Suspension

| April 20, 2012
  • Share:
  • Facebook
  • Pinterest
  • Reddit
  • Email

(Bay City News) A judge today sustained a tentative ruling denying a motion by suspended San Francisco Sheriff Ross Mirkarimi to overturn his suspension on official misconduct charges.

San Francisco Superior Judge Harold Kahn issued the tentative ruling Thursday and, after hearing from both Mirkarimi’s counsel and the city attorney’s office, said today that the matters raised by Mirkarimi’s counsel “can and should be addressed by the administrative procedure.”

On Monday, the city’s Ethics Commission will begin a hearing on the official misconduct charges. The commission will make a recommendation to the Board of Supervisors, which will issue the decision on whether to remove Mirkarimi from office.

Mirkarimi’s attorney David Waggoner raised concerns this morning that the ad-hoc process “is completely indefinite” and that Mirkarimi “cannot get and expect to get due process” without specific guidelines in place for the Ethics Commission hearing.

Kahn called the process “peculiar” but not so much so “that I should pull the plug before it starts.”

He invited Waggoner to return to court should something go “awry during the hearing” and should the defense’s hypothetical concerns materialize.

Mirkarimi’s attorneys had filed a petition for a writ to overturn the suspension, arguing that the definition of official misconduct was unconstitutionally vague and that the misconduct had to have occurred while the official was in office.

The alleged misconduct stems from a Dec. 31 domestic violence incident in which Mirkarimi grabbed the arm of his wife during an argument, causing a bruise.

Mirkarimi, 50, was still a member of the Board of Supervisors at the time of the incident and was not sworn in as sheriff until Jan. 8.

“All that can be raised before the Ethics Commission and before the Board of Supervisors,” Kahn said during this morning’s hearing.

Outside the courtroom, Deputy City Attorney Sherri Kaiser said, “I think the judge got it absolutely right that the place to decide this is before the Ethics Commission.”

Waggoner said that the defense was disappointed by yet respectful of Kahn’s decision.

He would not comment on whether Mirkarimi would testify at the Ethics Commission hearing.

However, moments earlier Kaiser said, “Certainly the sheriff is going to have to testify under oath and not just to the media.”

Days before his trial was expected to start last month, Mirkarimi pleaded guilty to a misdemeanor false imprisonment charge and was sentenced to three years’ probation and other penalties. He was suspended without pay by Mayor Ed Lee on March 21.

Related

Explore:

Category: Government, Law Enforcement, Legal, Politics, San Francisco

  • Share:
  • Facebook
  • Pinterest
  • Reddit
  • Email
  • http://www.facebook.com/ideaman David Elliott Lewis

    The lack of due process started when Mayor Lee brought Ross into the Mayor’s office to issue an ultimatum – demanding that he either resign or face suspension without pay. The mayor’s comments all happened within the first 30 seconds, before Ross had any opportunity to explain himself. Ross was stunned. Ross even offered his wife’s phone number and asked that the mayor talk to her to hear her side. The mayor wasn’t interested in calling her and, according to Ross, was not interested in hearing what Ross had to say. The mayor’s mind was made up.

    From the beginning, it appears that the powers that control this city wanted Ross out and will exploit any and every opportunity to evict him, an elected official who actually got more total votes than the mayor did.

    In my view this is a sad episode and the cause of justice is not being served.