How Engaged Are Students and Teachers in American Schools?

| April 15, 2014 | 15 Comments
  • Email Post
school

By Anya Kamenetz, Hechinger Report

Gallup recently released a major report on the State of American Schools. Their data paints a picture of schools performing as a complex ecosystem, with the wellbeing, engagement, and performance of teachers, students, and principals all intertwined.

The report combines decades of surveys of 5 million American teachers and principals with the results of the Gallup Student Poll, now billed as the largest survey of American students with 600,000 5th through 12 grade participants, and several large follow-up studies. Gallup’s also drawing on its background developing the Employee Engagement Survey, which has been administered to a total of almost 30 million people in all professions.

“The real bummer is [teachers] don’t feel their opinions matter.”

The Gallup polls ask students, teachers, principals, and other professionals about their levels of hope, emotional engagement, and well-being at work or school. While these qualities may seem like frills, they’ve been demonstrated over time to have powerful correlations with harder metrics, like a company’s profits or a school’s test scores. For example, in 2009, Gallup studied 78,000 students in 160 schools in eight states, finding that a one-percentage-point uptick in a school’s average student engagement was connected to an average six-point increase in reading achievement and eight points in math. Similarly, Gallup researchers have found in peer-reviewed studies that their “hope” measure was a better predictor of grades in college than SATs, ACTs or high school GPA. In a third study, students’ levels of hope accounted for almost half of the variation in math achievement and at least one-third of their variation in reading and science scores.

Brandon Busteed, the executive director of Gallup Education, says that in some ways, the point Gallup is making with this line of research is even more “provocative.” “We definitely want to show that these quote unquote ‘soft’ measures move the quote unquote ‘hard’ measures, like grades and test scores,” he said. “But we’re also asking: is engagement more important or are grades more important? If you ask a parent whether they’d rather have a kid who is getting mostly As and is only mildly interested in what they’re learning or mostly Bs and is super engaged, I can tell you what most parents would pick.”

So how are we doing on these soft measures? According to the survey, 55% of American students scored high on engagement, and just one in three score high on all three measures of hope, engagement and well-being.

Engagement measures have a lot to do with relationships and feeling valued. So it’s not surprising that there’s an intimate connection between the schoolroom engagement of students, and the workplace engagement of teachers. As the saying goes, “Our working conditions are our students’ learning conditions.”

Gallup found that students who agreed with the following two statements: 1. “My school is committed to building the strengths of each student” and 2. “I have at least one teacher who makes me excited about the future” were 30 times more likely to be engaged.

Unfortunately, most teachers are not in a position to share excitement with students. About 70% are classified as disengaged, which puts them on par with the workforce as a whole. This is surprising in some ways, because teachers score close to the top on measures that indicate that they find meaning in their life and see work as a calling. Unfortunately, the structures that teachers are working in–which may include high-stakes standardized testing and value-added formulas that evaluate their performance based on outside factors–seem to tug against their happiness. “The real bummer is they don’t feel their opinions matter,” Busteed says. K-12 teachers scored dead last among 12 occupational groups in agreeing with the statement that their opinions count at work, and also dead last on “My supervisor creates an open and trusting environment.”

This takes the measure directly to the top. Gallup’s study found that principal talent had a powerful impact on teacher engagement, which in turn affects student engagement. They recommend that principals adopt a more collaborative management style and help new teachers acclimate by putting them together to form partnerships with more experienced teachers.

Surveys and polls aren’t perfect, of course. But overall, the message of this research is a powerful indicator that we need to do a better job at looking at the full range of factors that affect school performance. Gallup is promoting its student poll to districts as another means of making decisions about what really counts in school.

This post originally appeared on The Hechinger Report.

Related

Explore:

  • Email Post
  • Pingback: How Engaged Are Students and Teachers in American Schools? | MindShift | Learning Curve

  • Pingback: Three Useful Posts On Student Engagement | Larry Ferlazzo’s Websites of the Day…

  • Pingback: Three Useful Posts On Student Engagement | Educational Policy Information

  • colosscat

    Poor editing– K-12 teachers scored dead last among 12 occupational groups in agreeing with the statement that their opinions count at work, and also dead last on “My supervisor creates an open and trusting environment.” is repeated twice, right after itself. I notice that it appears as this in the original article as well, but bolded–a quote, much as “The real bummer is [teachers] don’t feel their opinions matter.” is here. However, the current formatting on this page makes the extra text look like a mistake–like careless editing.

    • tbarseghian

      The error has been fixed. Thanks for calling it to our attention, colosscat.

  • CJmusic

    Curious to know where my comments disappeared to? They were here when I first posted?

    • tbarseghian

      I haven’t seen any other comments on this post. I’ve also checked the MindShift Disqus account and there are no comments from you. Are you sure you didn’t respond to the Hechinger link?

      • CJmusic

        I tried again. If the comments disappear again, I can send them to an email link if you would like.
        Thanks.

  • Pingback: Engagement and Empathy | KCELT

  • CJmusic

    My comments went something like this:

    I think that the choice of photo attached is extremely unfortunate. Not only is your headline in direct conflict with the picture (American schools with a Canadian school in the picture), but the smiling woman in the picture has brought some of the worst changes to classrooms across our province.

    The woman pictured is the current Premier of British Columbia (Canada) Christy Clark. Ms. Clark has been in direct conflict with teachers in BC since 2001 when she stood in the legislature as Minister of Education and announced she was “delighted” to bring in legislation that ended up closing 120 schools across the province, slashing budgets, reducing services for children (counsellors, resource teachers, ESL teachers, closing libraries, raising class sizes, reduced support for children with special needs), ripping up collective agreements, and so on. She was later elected premier, and she and her Liberal government actions with imposing contracts and ripping up collective agreements has been declared illegal by the court system TWICE. Yet she and her government continue to take the same actions over and over. School districts around the province are submitting budgets at this time of year, and are millions of dollars in debt as the government has downloaded huge costs to school districts with no support in funding.

    Yes, it looks like a great picture – but Ms. Clark is no friend to public education, and the situation in BC is anything but wonderful.

    I then considered the article and the picture a few more minutes, and commented that it is interesting that your bolded comments about “opinions of teachers not seeming to matter” was maybe more appropriate for this picture than you know. After all, how can a group of professionals stand up an protest and raise issues year after year after year and still have no improvements or respect?

    Thank you.

    • tbarseghian

      Thank you for your input. As you point out, since the image was not a reflection of American school as the headline and article indicate, we changed the image. I’m not sure why your original comment didn’t appear (sometimes this happens with Disqus), but it’s definitely showing up now.

  • Pingback: Week in Review – 18 April 2014 | USMA Library Blog

  • Pingback: Engagement, Hope, and Caring | Tech Salad

  • Pingback: Student Engagement | 2 educators

  • Pingback: The Best Posts & Articles On Student Engagement | Larry Ferlazzo’s Websites of the Day…