Why Confusion Can Be a Good Thing

| February 18, 2013 | 13 Comments
  • Email Post
134031979

We all know that confusion doesn’t feel good. Because it seems like an obstacle to learning, we try to arrange educational experiences and training sessions so that learners will encounter as little confusion as possible. But as is so often the case when it comes to learning, our intuitions here are exactly wrong. Scientists have been building a body of evidence over the past few years demonstrating that confusion can lead us to learn more efficiently, more deeply, more lastingly—as long as it’s properly managed.

How can this be? The human brain is a pattern-recognition machine. It evolved to identify related events or artifacts and connect them into a meaningful whole. This capacity serves us well in many endeavors, from recognizing the underlying themes in literature, to understanding the deep structure of a scientific or mathematical problem, to anticipating hidden complications and seeing their solutions in our work. Over time, exposure to these problem-solving situations gives us a subconscious familiarity with their essential nature that we can hardly articulate in words, but which we can easily put into action.

We short-circuit this process of subconscious learning, however, when we rush in too soon with an answer. It’s better to allow that confused, confounded feeling to last a little longer—for two reasons. First, not knowing the single correct way to resolve a problem allows us to explore a wide variety of potential explanations, thereby giving us a deeper and broader sense of the issues involved. Second, the feeling of being confused, of not knowing what’s up, creates a powerful drive to figure it out. We’re motivated to look more deeply, search more vigorously for a solution, and in so doing we see and understand things we would not have, had we simply been handed the answer at the outset.

Here, three ways that researchers have deliberately induced confusion, and how you can adapt them to your own learning:

1.   Expose yourself to confusing material. Reading a story by the surrealist writer Franz Kafka, or watching a movie by the eccentric filmmaker David Lynch, imposes on us a “meaning threat”—the uncomfortable feeling that nothing quite makes sense. We become motivated to find meaning somewhere, even if not in the original story or film, and this disposition actually makes us more accurate at picking out patterns. That’s the finding of Travis Proulx and Steven J. Heine, researchers who published their results in the journal Psychological Science. If you’re about to engage in any sense-making activity, from analyzing data to solving word problems, you may want to try delving into material that doesn’t make much sense first.

2.   Withhold the answers from yourself. We’ve heard a lot lately about the benefits of experiencing and overcoming failure. One way to get these benefits is to set things up so that you’re sure to fail—by tackling a difficult problem without any instruction or assistance. Manu Kapur, a researcher at the Learning Sciences Lab at the National Institute of Education of Singapore, has reported (in the Journal of the Learning Sciences) that people who try solving math

problems in this way don’t come up with the right answer—but they do generate a lot of ideas about the nature of the problems and about what potential solutions would look like, leading them to perform better on such problems in the future. Kapur calls this “productive failure,” and you can implement it in your own learning by allowing yourself to struggle with a problem for a while before seeking help or information.

3.   Test yourself before you learn. It sounds crazy, but studies by Nate Kornell, a psychology professor at Williams College, and others have found that trying to answer questions about material you haven’t even seen yet will help you learn that information better once you do encounter it. In an article published in the Journal of Experimental Psychology: Applied, Kornell and his coauthors theorize that searching our minds for answers (even if we come up empty) creates “fertile ground” in the brain for encoding the answer when it is eventually provided. You can do this yourself by flipping through a book or report you have to read and quizzing yourself on the chapter titles and section headings (many textbooks also supply lists of review questions which can be used as a pre-test). My favorite suggestion for using this technique: As you start to Google some piece of information, pause before looking at the results the search engine returns and try to come up with the answer yourself. Even if you can’t do it, you’ll be more likely to remember the information once it’s in front of your eyes. (You can find abstracts of the three studies mentioned here.)

Related
  • Email Post
  • Jon

    I like what you have here. It makes it seems like that even though our lives and thought processes can be/are hectic at times, that may be a good thing. Good work!

  • John

    Interesting article. This site has insightful looks at everyday situations. I feel smarter when I review a tweet of theirs.

  • Harris Levinson

    Regarding the value of confusion, I see this operating in the Spanish classes I teach entirely in the target language. I maintain that my students’ confusion is a good thing in that it can make them strive harder to find meaning and, eventually, discover it. Initially, this does not sit so well with the learners, but now I can present them (and their parents) with this article. Thank you.

  • Margaret Mills

    Brayden. I see what you mean… Alan`s stori is unimaginable… on monday I bought a great McLaren F1 after earning $4772 this-past/five weeks and just over ten k last month. it’s realy the nicest-work Ive ever done. I actually started four months/ago and almost immediately began to bring home over $76… per-hour. I use this website,, jump15.comCHECK IT OUT

  • Paul C.

    Very thought-provoking article. It provides additional support for the value of a pre-test before conducting a lesson.

  • Beth

    Thanks for sharing. I’m going to see if http://www.collegebookrenter.com has any of the books by the author mentioned.

  • Pingback: » Friday Findings Change of Perspective

  • Rohang

    liked the last one the most… would try for sure :)

  • http://www.facebook.com/maggie.lin.31105 Maggie Lin

    that is a very good article

  • Jerri

    I am not familiar with tweeter but I have had confusion in my life it is very frustrating until you can solve the confusion. Interesting article.

  • Pingback: Colouring Book – Episode 1 | wolfpeachblog

  • CLOWNFISH14

    Meh I had to read it for school purposes I didn’t really enjoy it. All I care about is a good grade.

  • CLOWNFISH14

    Oh yah which reminds me… does that mean really stupid people can become really smart people because of all the mistakes they have made in there life?