Donate

Scott Shafer

rss feed

Scott Shafer's Latest Posts

Analysis: Prop. 8 Case Unlikely to Result in Broad Right to Same-Sex Marriage

June 14, 2013 | 6:00 am

Analysis: Prop. 8 Case Unlikely to Result in Broad Right to Same-Sex Marriage

Posted by

Nearly five years after voters passed Proposition 8, the U.S. Supreme Court will soon decide the fate of California’s ban on same-sex marriage. But will that be the final word? When two same-sex couples filed a lawsuit challenging the constitutionality of Prop. 8, their attorney, Theodore Olson, described the issue in sweeping terms. “The case […]

Continue Reading

Prop 8 Judge Vaughn Walker: Courts’ Change on Same-Sex Marriage Was ‘Utterly Unimaginable’

June 12, 2013 | 6:00 pm

Prop 8 Judge Vaughn Walker: Courts’ Change on Same-Sex Marriage Was ‘Utterly Unimaginable’

Posted by

Ever since he struck down Proposition 8 in 2010, former federal judge Vaughn Walker has maintained a certain distance from the case. That’s probably wise, given that the Supreme Court has yet to make a final determination on his ruling. So when Walker called and invited me to hear him speak about LGBT legal issues […]

Continue Reading

The ‘Other’ Ted: No on 8 Attorney Prepares for Supreme Court Oral Arguments

March 25, 2013 | 2:00 pm

The ‘Other’ Ted: No on 8 Attorney Prepares for Supreme Court Oral Arguments

Posted by

When Theodore Boutrous, Jr. hopped on the phone the other day from Washington, he was giddy. “We just got a unanimous ruling at the Supreme Court!” He was referring to the 9-0 decision on behalf of his client, an insurance company fighting a class action case.

I asked Boutrous, who goes by “Ted”, how many times he’s argued in front of the Supreme Court. “Twice, “ he said.  “And I’ve got 18 votes!” When I suggested he should retire while he has a perfect record, he emailed back “It’s tempting!”

File photo. Theodore Boutros, Media attorney speaks at a press conference after the Michael Jackson's pre-trial hearing on June 25, 2004. (Joshua Gates Weisberg-Pool/Getty Images)
Since the start of the Prop. 8 debate in federal court four years ago, Boutrous has been overshadowed by his high profile colleague, attorney Theodore Olson. Both are partners at Gibson, Dunn & Crutcher (Boutrous in the Los Angeles office, Olson in D.C.) and have worked together for nearly 30 years. Olson is renowned in legal circles as a leading conservative, which makes his pairing with David Boies (whom he faced on opposite sides of the Bush v. Gore case in 2000) so interesting.

Boutrous  may not get the “ink” they get, but he’s been an integral part of the legal strategy against Prop. 8.

Continue Reading

Prop. 8 at the Supreme Court: What’s at Stake

March 25, 2013 | 5:30 am

Prop. 8 at the Supreme Court: What’s at Stake

Posted by

On Valentine’s Day last month, about a dozen gay and lesbian couples showed up at San Francisco City Hall. They wanted something they knew they couldn’t have: A marriage license.

Same-sex couple Frank Capley (L) and Joe Alfano (R) look on before staging a sit-in protest after same-sex couples were denied marriage licenses from the San Francisco county clerk on Valentine's Day. (Justin Sullivan/Getty Images)

The protest, organized by Marriage Equality USA, happens every year. And every year the couples are turned away.

Thom Watson from Daly City came with his partner.

“You’re really never fully prepared for what it’s going to feel like yet again to be turned down for something that you want so badly and that other people take for granted,” Watson said.

The right to get that legal document from a county clerk is what Tuesday’s U.S. Supreme Court hearing is all about: whether California’s Proposition 8 — a constitutional amendment defining marriage as a union of a man and a woman — violates equal protection under the law guaranteed by the U.S. Constitution.

Continue Reading

Prop. 8: How We Got Here (Video)

March 22, 2013 | 11:00 am

Prop. 8: How We Got Here (Video)

Posted by

You might say the long journey of Proposition 8 began May 15, 2008, when a ruling came down from the California Supreme Court declaring that gay and lesbian couples had a legal right to get married.

 San Francisco mayor Gavin Newsom (R) marries same-sex couple Del Martin (R) and Phyllis Lyon (L) during a private ceremony at San Francisco City Hall June 16, 2008. (Marcio Jose Sanchez-Pool/Getty Images)

Mayor Gavin Newsom celebrated at City Hall with a crowd of thrilled San Franciscans, “This door’s wide open now. It’s gonna happen whether you like it or not. This is the future, and it’s now.”

It was a historic ruling, but not a done deal.

The ruling infuriated supporters of traditional marriage, including Randy Thomasson, with Protect Marriage.

“It will spur Californians to go to the polls to override the judges and protect marriage licenses for one man and one woman in the California constitution,” Thomasson said.

Continue Reading

California Poll Finds Widespread Support For Same-Sex Marriage

February 28, 2013 | 6:01 am

California Poll Finds Widespread Support For Same-Sex Marriage

Posted by

Couples challenging Prop 8 pose before an Appeals Court hearing in Dec. 2010. (Scott Shafer/KQED)

Four years after narrowly  banning same-sex marriage in California through Proposition 8, state voters now approve of gay nuptials by 61 to 32 percent, a new Field Poll finds. That’s a couple of points more in favor of same-sex marriage than in last year’s poll, which found a 59 to 34 percent margin of support. In 2010, the numbers in favor were 52 to 48 percent.

The survey, released today, finds more support than opposition to gay marriage in every demographic subgroup except registered Republicans and self-identified conservatives.

The poll comes on the last day for friend of the court or “amicus” briefs to be filed in the U.S. Supreme Court case challenging Prop. 8.

Continue Reading

February 14, 2013 | 4:51 pm

Photos: Same-Sex Marriage Advocates Disrupt SF City Hall

Posted by

Several gay and lesbian couples disrupted business at San Francisco’s city hall Friday morning. The couples entered the city clerk’s office asking for something they knew they couldn’t get … a marriage license.

“We love each other and we want the rights that everyone else gets. I don’t want if I die that she can’t get my Social Security or come take my house because we’re not legally married,” said Linda Gates who attended the protest with her partner Betty.

During the demonstration, heterosexual couples, including Mario Caballeros and his fiancé Jessica from Richmond, were told to come back later.

“That just sucks. They can pick another time and another reason or do it the right way,” said Caballeros. “Just taking up peoples’ time. We have to wait just for them to get their little word out? That’s not cool, you know?”

Protesters sang and chanted until sheriff’s deputies ordered them to disperse. Thirteen protesters who refused to leave were detained for just a few minutes, then released without being charged.

Continue Reading

A Church Divided: Religion, Morality Never Far From Issue of LGBT Rights

February 14, 2013 | 11:49 am

A Church Divided: Religion, Morality Never Far From Issue of LGBT Rights

Posted by

KQED 9 will broadcast A Church Divided on Friday, Feb 15, at 7:30 p.m. The television documentary will take viewers to the United Methodist Church’s convention in Tampa, FL, where delegates from around the world gathered to decide the future of the church and its official policy on gays and lesbians. Below, show host and […]

Continue Reading

January 18, 2013 | 3:09 pm

Interview: Zoe Lofgren Says GOP Faces Pressure on Immigration Reform

Posted by

As President Obama’s second inauguration draws near, the Capitol seems oddly quiet. On Thursday, Republican House members retreated to a golf course in Williamsburg, Virginia, for a secret strategy session on how to regain some political mojo. Democrats, meanwhile, are thinking guns, immigration and the coming battle over raising the debt ceiling. I’ve met with  […]

Continue Reading

January 18, 2013 | 2:07 pm

Inaugural Notebook: Fashion A-Listers Ed Lee, Jean Quan to Attend California Show

Posted by

It’s always fun to truck up to Capitol Hill and interview our elected representatives — but what can top seeing them at a California fashion show in the Ritz Hotel in Georgetown!? No, they’re not going to walk the runway (get real). But on Saturday afternoon a bipartisan group of political gliterati will attend the […]

Continue Reading