Beyond the iPad: Schools’ Choices In Tablets Grow

| September 4, 2013 | 14 Comments
  • Email Post

158752997

Just a couple of short years ago, the presence of tablets in schools was an exceptional phenomenon. This year, as students across the country go back to school, the presence of tablets is far more common in classrooms. Though it’s definitely not the norm yet, many more schools and districts are investing in the devices for a variety of reasons.

A recent study conducted by Harris Interactive for publisher Pearson showed that, while 44 percent of kids are using some kind of tablet for learning, 92 percent of kids surveyed believe that using a tablet in school will change how they learn in the future. And 90 percent of students said using a tablet makes learning more fun.

Though the iPad gets most of the limelight, other tablet makers like Intel, Samsung, Google, and Amplify are getting into the game, providing a variety of education programming, apps, and curriculum. From plug-in paint tools to magnifying glasses, tablet makers are competing for a share of the education market by creating new ways to use tablets in class.

Though this is not an exhaustive list of every type of tablet used in schools, here are the top-rated devices for education and a look what’s distinct about each one.

  • VINCI Android Tablet for young children, ages 1.5-9 years. ($110-$184.99)

VM-5610_View_1

This affordable tablet is aimed at the youngest students, and has won an International CES Innovations Design and Engineering Award for its unique VINCI curriculum. VINCI has broken down learning apps into two groups — Home and School — and categorized both by age and subject. The for-school portion’s curriculum categories are Early Math, Language Arts, Early Science, Thematic Units, and Learning Centers, but using the WiFi on the tablet allows access to download more apps from Google Play. Tablets come with tempered glass screens and sturdy plastic cases, and are available in three options: the Tab II 7”, the Tab III M 5”, which supports child voice recognition and can be networked together for children to play in groups, and the Tab MV 5”, which is a WiFi tablet and smartphone combination. The 7″ version is the School Edition. The downside is that most apps aren’t appropriate for older children, and some wonder if it’s just a toy disguised as a “learning device.”

  • Amplify Tablet for K-12 Education. ($299-$349 for tablets, with 2-year curriculum subscription fees ranging from $99-$179)

Amplify_Tablet-2x_414_313News Corp’s entrance into the tablets-for-education market promises technology that connects students and teachers while being Common Core aligned. The 10” tablet, featuring the Android 4.2 Jelly Bean operating system, comes preloaded with Amplify’s exclusive education platform as well as lots of Google products, including Goolge Play, Google Hangout, Google Messenger and Google Talkback. Amplify also offers professional development both at the district level and to teachers to learn how to integrate the tablets – and curriculum – into classrooms. One of Amplify’s strengths seems to be how tailored it is to educators: “This actually offers features to teachers aimed at delivering instant feedback and differentiated instruction,” writes Terrence O’Brien at Endgadget. “Everything from taking attendance and blocking distracting apps, to polling students comprehension and pushing supplemental materials to those that need it can be managed from the educator’s unit. There’s also the ability to build custom lesson plans called Playlists, that can incorporate material from locally stored textbooks, pre-loaded Khan Academy videos and the internet.”

  • XO Tablet by One Laptop Per Child ($149.00)

product-shot01Designed by Yves Behar’s Fuseproject, this affordable 7” tablet meant to be used around the globe is offered by the nonprofit One Laptop per Child. The WiFi enabled tablet features a touch-screen made of multi-touch, flexible plastic, “so many hands can play and learn together.” The tablet can be used as a horizontal book, a portrait-style book, can turn into a full keyboard and features both a front and back-facing camera. Featuring special Android-based XO software and available in English and Spanish and soon may other languages, the XO Learning System is built around 12 “dreams,” or professions children may be interested in.

T3100_400x400_large1_vfSamsung’s tablet comes in four sizes – from 7” to 10.1” – and Samsung’s brand new Galaxy 3 7.0 is an entry-level tablet that promises a lower price point ($199.99), and has just announced plans of creating a tablet just for kids. Samsung is playing in the major-brand tablet market, with large processors and featuring front and back-facing cameras enabled for photo and video. While there have been reports that Samsung will be creating a Learning Hub similar to iTunes U in the near future, for now Samsung offers Samsung School, which seeks to be a learning management system for educators. Features include an interactive whiteboard that can simultaneously appear on student tablet screens, conduct Q&As and polls, and organize ebooks and apps, too.

ies-sh-hf-angle-1x1.jpg.rendition.cq5dam.webintel.168.168Intel just released its plans to add a tablet for education to its line of products, featuring a powerful processor and tools promised to be especially useful in education — including an e-Reader, painting tools and accessories, and a suite of tools made for science exploration, like an attachable magnifying glass and thermal probe. The tablet, which runs on Android operating system code-named Ice Cream Sandwich, boasts an extra-long battery life and comes preloaded with Intel’s Education Software package, which includes special math and science apps like the Education Lab Camera, SPARKvue and Kno Textbooks.

Screen Shot 2013-09-03 at 4.46.11 PMWith reportedly over 10 million tablets already in schools, iPad continues to lead the way in using handheld technology to further education. Both the 9.7” tablet and the 7.9” Mini feature front and back-facing cameras, access to thousands of books and textbooks through iBooks, the App Store and iTunes U. While Apple remains proprietary in integrating all its products to work together, it has also has smartly eschewed fancy add-ons and accessories, seeming to focus on providing the best learning games, apps and content to satisfy schools’ very real needs to integrate technology into classrooms.

en-INTL_L_Dell_Latitude_10_CWF-01015_RM7_mnco

Dell’s tablet computer, which runs on Windows 8 and contains Intel Inside processors, promises much of the same technology as other large-brand tablets – WiFi, cameras, touch-screen technology as well as Microsoft Office Home and Student. While it appears that Dell offers no education-specific software or features, much of the technology available, like Google Play for Education, will be easy to access.

Screen Shot 2013-09-03 at 4.50.31 PM

While some consider the Google Chromebook laptop as lean and efficient as a tablet, Google is getting into the table market with its Nexus series. And, with the announcement of Google Play for Education coming sometime this fall, Google’s Nexus tablet will surely be a major competitor for the Apple/iTunes education market. While Nexus offers nearly the same tablet experience as other large brand tablets like iPad and Samsung, the Nexus is preloaded with all the Google products – Google Messenger, Hangout, Play and Talkback, and more – and makes integrating what students are already doing on Google seamless and easy.

Clarification: The current version of this post includes the correct information about Intel’s Android operating system and specifies that the 7-inch VINCI tablet is used by schools.

Related

Explore:

  • Email Post
  • Pingback: Beyond the iPad: Schools’ Choices In Tablets Grow | MindShift : SCOE News Reader

  • Pingback: On Earth InfoLastest TABLET News | On Earth Info

  • Pingback: Beyond the iPad: Schools’ Choices In Tablets Grow « Reviews Technology

  • http://etiennedouaze.com/ Etienne Douaze

    Intel tablet: ‘The tablet, which runs on Windows 8 using Android 4.0 Jelly Bean’. Mmmmh, I don’t think so. It is one or the other: Windows 8 OR Android…

  • Pingback: Latest Tablets News | Edgar's Product Reviews

  • Dan Yang

    Thanks for putting VINCI en top of your list. We just want to clarify that the VINCI school version is only our 7 inch signature tablet with the red bumper. The other models you mentioned are home version.
    I’m also puzzled that your article didn’t mention curriculum much while talking about school application. School means pedagogy, curricular materials, assessment, grades etc.. Any serious tablet based implementation will need to take care of for example how content gets to not 1, but 30 tablets (in a classroom) or 30,000 tablets (in a school districts). Can you imagine somebody spends their days downloading apps one by one?
    And then, what about youngest learners? Research has shown direct correlation between kindergarten failure with high school drop out. How do you give incentive to the little kids so they don’t spend billions for intervention at higher grades? Yes VINCI is indeed specialized in early ed as well as primary grades. I hope you have a chance to watch our case study at http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=eUShnnQ2fZ8

    • tbarseghian

      Thanks for your clarification, Dan. We added the fact that the 7-inch tablet is the one targeted at schools to the article. There’s much more content about tablets in schools here: http://blogs.kqed.org/mindshift/2013/05/the-future-of-tablets-in-education-potential-vs-reality/ This short article was a quick rundown (not exhaustive) of the top-rated and most used devices.

      • Dan Yang

        Thanks so much! I just hope that having a focused selection of curricular materials such as game-based lessons and printed books, for a specific age range P-3, which is called “foundation years”, should be considered more as an upside rather than downside. You know, pain killers are widely used but it can’t solve your problem. When it comes to helping all the kids to lay a solid foundation to succeed in school, a specialist approach could prove to be way more effective. Younger the children are, more individual attention they need. A little crack at K level, if not repaired, means a big hole at high grades.

  • Pingback: Zenya » » Classroom Technology That Gets an A+

  • Rachel Brent

    Dan raisers an excellent point and I feel that comparing educational tablets like the VINCI (or Hatch’s iStartSmart Mobile solution) to hardware only tablets is like comparing apples to oranges.

    When a school purchases a hardware only tablet, they’ve purchased a powerful piece of technology, but it’s only as good as any one teacher’s comfort level with technology. If you have a teacher that is familiar with how apps work, has the time to research the best possible educational apps on the market, and then can work those apps into larger curriculum requirements (like CORE or Creative Curriculum) than that’s excellent! However, that’s one teacher in one classroom. The teacher next door might view tablets as just another device to play solitaire on.

    When a school purchases a tablet like the iStartSmart or VINCI they’re not buying a toy, they’re purchasing an education solution that addresses these issues head on. For example, the iStartSmart has researched based learning environments specifically targeted towards preschool aged children. It tracks a child’s learning over 18 core skill areas which have been aligned to National Head Start Association, National Association for the Education of Young Children, National Research Council, National Early Literacy Panel, and state standards to promote school readiness. Additionally, when purchasing an educational tablet, you should be also gaining access to a learning monitoring system to track a child’s progress over time.

    Finally, I’d like to address educational tablets being toys “disguised as a ‘learning device’”. It should go without saying that not all educational games/apps are created equal. I can’t speak for VINCI as I have not seen their programs firsthand, but Hatch’s learning games are designed to be fun, educational, and scaffolded to grow with a child as they master different academic concepts. It’s hard to believe even the most popular $0.99 educational app can do that. With a little investigation it should be relatively easy to spot what programs put style over substance. If I could comment similarly on that Wired Article, I would!

    An excellent review article overall, but I’d be interested in seeing a follow up article that compares only educational tablet solutions, perhaps divided by targeted age group?

  • Pingback: Latest Tablets News | Emmanuel's Product Blog

  • Pingback: The Impact of ICT in Literacy Standards: Weekly News Round-up – 02, December 2013 | Tablets For Schools

  • Pingback: Tables for Educators and Students in College | Learning from Lorelle

  • Pingback: Technology in Elementary Education: Better preparing our children for tomorrow | alexbongard