1550 Hyde Cafe & Wine Bar: Reviews

1550 Hyde Cafe & Wine Bar: Reviews | restaurant info | recipe | watch episode (requires RealPlayer: windows | mac) | view photo gallery (flickr.com)

1550 Hyde1550 Hyde1550 Hyde
Grilled Dayboat Scallops with fennel-rucola salad and romesco sauce; Fried Rabbit with seme di melone, cucumbers, butter lettuce and lemon; Scharffen Berger Bittersweet Chocolate Pot de Crème with shortbread cookies


TonyaName: Tonya
Occupation: Owner of Women’s Clothing Boutique
Location: San Francisco
Favorite Restaurant: 1550 Hyde Cafe & Wine Bar
Reviewed 1550 Hyde Cafe & Wine Bar: Saturday, October 1, 2005

The restaurant is located at the top of the hill on Hyde Street, so you get an impossibly romantic view of Russian Hill, with the cable car going by every fifteen minutes. The charming server presents you with a one-page description of tonight’s wine flight, which is written in way that instantly entices and gives an education to the novice and the expert. You get a vivid description of each of the three wines (color, “notes,” and finish), as well as insider information about the region and the family of winemakers.

It’s clear that every dish is prepared with care and love. The ingredients are fresh and the elements of each dish come together to maximum effect. This is refined rustic fare, which is on par with pricier restaurants like Hawthorne Lane or Boulevard.

I can’t say enough good things about 1550 Hyde — every aspect of the experience is memorable.


BryanName: Bryan
Occupation: Musician
Location: San Francisco
Favorite Restaurant: Everett & Jones Barbeque
Reviewed 1550 Hyde Cafe & Wine Bar: Thursday, October 13, 2005

It was a classic San Francisco evening. The fog had rolled in, and it was chilly and a bit windy. As we walked up Pacific we heard the foghorns and my lady’s teeth chattering up a storm. I had a good feeling about this place after I had done some research online. We entered 1550 Hyde and found it to be warm and comfortable — perfect for this night. A young woman greeted us with an inviting smile and asked us if we would like a glass of wine at the bar while we waited. Looking over the wine menu, I was a bit overwhelmed. I really don’t know too much about wines and this list was intimidating. So… I decided to try something I’ve never heard of before: a 2003 Castaño Hécula from Spain. It was quite tasty and a bit spicy. My fiancé chose the Scharffenberger sparkling wine; she liked that. About halfway through our wine, we were seated at a cute table in the front corner.

I was checking out the clientele as we strolled through the place. There was a good mix of middle-aged folks in Dockers and sweaters and a young hipster club vibe. However, one woman — a new mother — was in sweats. The décor was very minimal; not much on the walls. Low lighting made for a very intimate setting. The building was a renovated Edwardian with wainscoted wood walls, small crown shelving about four feet up, and warmly painted plaster for the ceiling.

On with the show. They had some interesting selections on the menu like rabbit liver terrine, fried rabbit, wild local salmon, and stewed lamb leg. To start with, I chose the heirloom tomato and Bibb lettuce salad with Green Goddess dressing and grilled bread. This was very tasty. The tomatoes were perfect — they were not soft and mealy at all. They were ripe and bursting with flavor. The Bibb lettuce was delicate with just the slightest crunch. All coated (not drowned) in the dressing, so I could taste the food. Fantastic! My lady ordered the grilled Dayboat scallops with a fennel-rucola salad and romesco sauce. She absolutely loved it. I tasted it, and I wasn’t crazy about it, but I also didn’t order it. At this point, we were ready for more wine. I like Zinfandel, so I got one. It was a 2003 Ridge “Three Valleys” from Sonoma County; I really liked it. My favorite person in the world selected a 2004 Le Pigeoulet Syrah blend from France. She thought it was yummy. However, she should’ve asked our server for a better selection because it didn’t match up well with her meal.

For our main entrees, I ordered the Hoffman Farms chicken, which was cooked under a brick and served with chanterelles, potato purée, and caramelized onions and Bloomsdale spinach. One word…AWESOME! My chicken was boneless, in one piece, and had both white and dark meat. It had that “crispity” skin on it that I love so very much, and the meat was moist and flavorful. The mushrooms were an excellent complement to the fowl and the potatoes and spinach were a great contrast, both in texture and taste. My soon-to-be wife opted for the fettuccini with braised Berkshire pork, Bloomsdale spinach and pecorino. She loved hers as well. The pasta tasted homemade and was cooked to perfection. My girl can get a bit fussy when it come to pasta, but this passed the test with flying colors. All in all, four stars so far.

And now the true test: the dessert. I got a sweet tooth. I’m not gonna beat around the bush. My sweetheart chose the stonefruit bread pudding with goat’s milk ice cream. The bread pudding was out of this world — sweet and cakey with just the right amount of tartness from the fruit. The goats milk ice cream, on the other hand, was…well…gross. This is a flavor that may be for someone with a refined palate, but it was just too strong and it overpowered the brilliant flavor of the bread pudding. I thought it tasted like the barn floor — yeech!! I ordered the Scharffenberger dark chocolate pot de crème, which is basically some fancy uptown puddin’. Man, oh, man! I thought I died and went to heaven. This was so, so good it should be illegal. You can taste the fine dark chocolate smothered in thick whipped cream in every bite. The texture was rich and full-bodied, and the cream tempered the strong chocolate flavor to perfection. A great end to a great meal.

I would definitely recommend 1550 Hyde to many friends, and we plan on coming back in the near future.


MarkName: Mark
Occupation: Art & Antique Dealer
Location: San Francisco
Favorite Restaurant: Lark Creek Inn
Reviewed 1550 Hyde Cafe & Wine Bar: Saturday, October 1, 2005

As I walked up Pacific Avenue towards Hyde Street, this little gem of a restaurant came into view. It is located on a picturesque, tree-lined San Francisco street, which is on the cable car line, so you can watch the cable cars go clanking by while you dine. One thing is for certain — this small, tucked-away, neighborhood eatery knows about fine food and wine. Upon entering, the host promptly greeted us and sat us at one of the coveted window seats at the front of the restaurant. The place is U-shaped with both of the main seating areas flanking the centered, beautifully lit, marble wine bar. The interior is tastefully minimalist with painted gray wainscoting and beautiful, curved mica covered sconces, which dot the otherwise empty walls. The handsome bar is truly the centerpiece of this small restaurant. Placed off to one side of the bar was a very large galvanized vessel filled with exotic Bird of Paradise and other glorious flora, which made for a great focal point to an otherwise stark interior. Soon after being seated, our waiter greeted us, and to my surprise, he was an acquaintance from many years ago. We shared a mutual friend who was in the restaurant business, and he had worked at several places where I had dined over the years. We were both pleased that our paths had once again crossed. Needless to say, we had impeccable service. He guided me through my first visit at 1550 Hyde. He knows what he’s doing and it shows.

I started with the grilled Dayboat scallops, topped with a romesco sauce and surrounded by a fennel-rocket salad. Two perfectly grilled scallops came on wooden skewers — each garnished with some of the spicy red romesco sauce — and they were surrounded by a lightly-dressed arugula and fennel salad. The scallops were cooked completely through, yet they were still supple and delicious, and the tangy red sauce had just the right amount of heat to complement them. My only suggestion would be to remove the skewers in the kitchen before serving (The angst starts when I see something served on a skewer in a restaurant. I have visions of food flying across the table upon skewer removal, though this was not the case this time.)

There was a nice selection of six entrees, but if I see rabbit on the menu it’s almost always my choice. So, when I saw the fried rabbit with semi di melone, cucumbers, butter lettuce and lemon, I knew that had to be mine. A rabbit half was cut into three pieces and encrusted with a crisp, non-greasy cornmeal coating. As you cut through the crust, you reveal the juicy and delicious rabbit meat. The semi di melone (short-grained, rice-shaped pasta) was placed to the side of the rabbit and served in a leaf of Bibb lettuce. It was a less heavy version of a risotto but it was made with pasta and served at room temperature. The cool slices of cucumber were a nice balance to the hot, fried rabbit and the tasty creamy texture of the pasta. A squeeze of fresh lemon added a bit of brightness to the dish. This mix of flavors and textures was sublime.

My dinner guest had the fresh fettuccini with braised Berkshire pork, Bloomsdale spinach and pecorino. This dish was just a bit off the mark. Though the pasta was perfectly done, and the braised pink-colored pork could not have been more tender, all of these subtle flavors were overpowered by the heavy-handed use of the distinctly flavored pecorino cheese. Being raised in a southern Italian family, I was fed pecorino cheese at a very early age and I love the taste. Many times I prefer using it instead of the more popular Parmigiano-Reggiano in pasta dishes. In this instance, it was a bit too much and the delicate flavors of the other ingredients were lost. It wasn’t horrible, but it wasn’t great.

My dessert — the chocolate pot de crème — was great. It was incredible! It is a rich, smooth, dense, dark chocolate pudding with a bit of whipped cream on top and two shortbread cookies on the side. That, and an espresso, was the perfect end to an absolutely delightful meal. The wine our waiter suggested was a French Burgundy — the 2001 Olivier Guyot, Marsanny, “La Montagne.” It was fantastic and had black fruit flavors, a hint of plum, and a wonderful, slightly smoky nose. It was a terrific match for the rabbit and pork dishes and it was organic to boot.

This restaurant has superior quality organic food, which is well priced and creatively prepared. They have an extraordinarily diverse, and also very reasonably priced, wine list (Try their “Flight Plans,” which is a sampling of three 4 oz. pours of different wines from a particular wine-growing region.) The staff and owners are friendly, knowledgeable, and helpful. When we arrived at six pm, the place was virtually empty but by seven pm, every table was full, so I strongly suggest making reservations since it is a fairly small establishment. 1550 Hyde is a terrific find and I encourage anyone who loves great food and wine to try this little neighborhood treasure.

No tags for this post.
  • Sue

    My husband and I visited 1550 Hyde for a belated Valentine’s dinner this past Wednesday & we had a great experience. We got there early and at first the atmosphere seemed sparse but as the place filled, it livened up. The wine flight featured Pinot Noirs and was educational & fun. I was a bit disappointed that they didn’t have the chicken under a brick that night but settled for the pheasant dish – it was very tasty. My husband tried the rabbit & loved it – great flavors & nice size portions. We splurged & both got desserts. I had to order the chocolate pot de creme (lived up to my high expectations – it’s everything chocolate strives to be) and he got the special which was a rum cake with espresso layerings & shaved chocolate. Visually bland but what an explosion of flavors in your mouth. Overall, we had a wonderful time & would visit again.

  • Yvette

    I have been to this restaurant twice since seeing it reviewed on CPBA. I love this place and it has become my favorite semi-upscale SF restaurant. I am going again this week and look forward to it.

    On my second visit I had the MOST delicious rack of port (never heard of that before). It had a delicious crust on the outside and was completely juicy on the inside. Fantastic! I will never forget this dish and I hope they have it again. Luckily 1550 Hyde St. has a website where they post their menu, as it changes regularly.

    http://home.earthlink.net/~zootster/

    Parking is pretty hard even with a Mini Cooper. If this restaurant was in my neighborhood (Bernal Heights) I would eat there a couple of times a month. It’s great and is exactly the kind of restaurant I had been yearning for.

  • MM4L

    We recetly caught the re-run of this show and immediately made a reservation for the very next night at 1550 Hyde.. what a dissapointment. The food was mediocre (it was clearly an attempt at good home cooking that fell short) and the prices were decent (for the City), but we certainly won’t be going there again.

    The 3 worst things (in order of annoyance):
    The rude hostess (brunette with narrow-rimmed glasses)
    Generally disorganized and dirty tables
    Parking REALLY sucks in this neighborhood (as it does in most of SF)

    The 3 best things (in order of appreciation):
    The green goddess salad
    The wine flight
    Our waitress (the redhead)

    We made a reservation and showed up 5 minutes early.. apparently they open at 6 and aren’t ready until after 6. No menus, tables were sticky and dirty from the night before. We had to call the buss boy over to clean up. The hostess was very abrupt with us (and everyone, so it seemed). One couple got up and left after they were seated. I wish we had, but I fell like I had won the friggin’ LOTTO in finding a free/legal parking space only a block away!

    The green goddess salad was the highlight of the meal. The wine flight with the (pork) prix fixe menu was quite nice and our waitress was very polite and attentive.

    The meals we had (the pork and the chicken under a brick) as well as the desserts (the apple crustini/tart with vanilla ice cream and espresso affogatto were all so-so and unfortunately not worth repeating or recommending. Total for 2 (with tip) was just over $100.